The Academy’s Winners V.S. MY Winners
(Image from Pixabay)
The Academy awards, a.k.a. The Oscars, were held on Sunday, February 9th this year, and like many, I sat with bated breath to see who would walk out with a golden statue. Usually, the Oscars have some element of drama in the award ceremony. Either there’s some sort of upset (Olivia Colman winning Best Actress in a Leading role over Glenn Close last year) or an incredibly dramatic moment (I’m talking about La La Land being mistakenly called for best picture instead of Moonlight level of dramatic). I was excited to see what this year’s award ceremony had in store only to be disappointed. This year’s Oscars was, to say the least, boring. Most of the award winners had been predicted months in advance and it took the razzle dazzle out of the whole affair. Plus, there were some awards that I would have given to a completely different person. So, in the spirit of adding so retroactive pizazz to the Oscars, I thought I would write about how I would have doled out the awards in comparison to the Academy’s picks. (Disclaimer: I did not talk about every category covered by the Oscars because I did not see any of the movies in the categories I decided not to cover. The categories I do not cover in this post are as follows: Best Documentary Feature, Best Documentary Short Subject, Best Animated Short Film, and Best Live Action Short Film. I will also not be listing all the nominees. If you would like to see all of the nominees listed, click here.)
*SPOILER ALERT: IF YOU HAVE NOT SEEN THESE MOVIES AND DO NOT WANT TO HAVE ANY OF THEM SPOILED FOR YOU, STOP READING. I TEND TO GO INTO THE SPECIFICS OF THE MOVIES. THANK YOU*
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A SUPPORTING ROLE WINNER: Brad Pitt in “Once Upon a Time… In Hollywood”
My Pick: Brad Pitt in “Once Upon a Time… In Hollywood”
Brad Pitt deserved this award. He was long overdue an acting Academy Award and I’m glad he nabbed it for this performance
BEST ANIMATED FEATURE FILM OF THE YEAR WINNER: “Toy Story 4” (Josh Cooley, Mark Nielson and Jonas Rivera)
My Pick: “Frozen II”
I have a bone to pick with the Academy when it comes to this category. Frozen II deserved to win Best Animated Feature and IT WASN’T EVEN NOMINATED! There are so many reasons this movie deserved this award. (1) It was record-breaking. It became the highest-grossing animated movie in history, beating its predecessor. That’s unheard of, especially for a Disney movie! How many times have you heard of a movie sequel doing BETTER than the first? I know I haven’t heard of many. (2) I was not the biggest fan of the 1st Frozen and I was reluctant to see the 2nd, but the story really won me over. Looking into the origins of Elsa’s powers was such a brilliant idea and the more in-depth look into the fantastical world of Arrendale was fascinating! (3) The animation was astounding. You can’t tell me the ocean sequence where Elsa tries to reach Ahtohallen didn’t take your breath away! The ocean looked REAL! I have never seen animation as detailed as in this movie. (3) The songs were amazing. There were funny childlike ones like “When I am Older” and “Lost in the Woods” that made me crack up in the theater. There were also songs that caused me to sob like a baby like “Show Yourself” and “The Next Right Thing.” To say “Into the Unknown” is the only amazing song from this movie would be ignorant. I was blown away by the others. (4) This movie was a lot more mature than other Disney films and other animated films in general. It didn’t talk down to children. It dealt with hard-to-talk-about topics like grief, depression, and the fear of things changing that people deal with in adulthood. I really identified with the characters and their struggles and left the theater fully touched by the movie’s message. (5) As a personal preference, I preferred “Frozen II” to “Frozen for one important reason: I actually liked Anna in the 2nd movie. Nothing against Kristen Bell because I love her, but Anna used to annoy me in the first movie. “Frozen II” matured her and rounded her out as a character. She felt real. She felt like a person trying to be positive in some of the bleakest moments of her life, unlike in the first movie where she came across as a girl being quirky for the sake of being quirky. All in all, this movie was brilliant. It deserved better and was definitely snubbed.
ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY WINNER: “Parasite” (Screenplay by Bong Joon Ho, Han Jin Won; Story by Bong Joon Hon)
My Pick: “Knives Out” (Written by Rian Johnson)
I am going to get a lot of hate for this, but remember, this is my opinion! “Parasite” was the darling of the Academy’s eye this year. It broke records with its wins and number of wins. It had a very compelling story about class conflict and social inequality. Over all, I enjoyed “Parasite’s” story. Being that as it may, I really think “Knives Out” deserved this award. Reworking a popular genre is a very difficult thing to do. Agatha Christie really defined what a good murder mystery is, and as a society, we are used to the formula. The obvious culprit is never the murderer. If the detective is a professional, they are usually sophisticated and foreign, usually from Europe. If the murder involves the death of a wealthy influential character, the motive is always for the inheritance. Rian subverts all our expectations. Ransom is the obvious pick for the murderer. We immediately rule him out, but IT IS HIM in the end. Detective Benoit Blanc is played by Daniel Craig, a famous British actor, but he ends up having a southern drawl. And finally, the murder covered up to be a suicide ended up being a suicide. No one actually poisoned Harlan Thrombey, and his death was caused by him slitting his own throat. For all these reasons, Johnson’s script is brilliant and deserved the win.
ADAPTED SCREENPLAY WINNER: “Jojo Rabbit” (Screenplay by Taika Waititi)
My Pick: “Little Women” (Written for the screen by Greta Gerwig) OR “Jojo Rabbit” (Screenplay by Taika Waititi)
I am pretty sad that “Little Women” didn’t take this one home. The script is heart-warming and heart-wrenching at the exact same time. The dialogue was brilliant and really brought these beloved characters to life. With this book having so many movie adaptations, it can be really easy to copy those that came before you, but Gerwig really made it her own. That being said, I am over all satisfied that ”Jojo Rabbit” took this one. Waititi somehow made a film about the Hitler Youth, Nazi Germany, and the Holocaust light hearted without insulting those affected by the tragic events. That is an achievement in film if I’ve ever seen one. Plus, seeing Taika Waititi, a Jewish person-of-color, play Adolf Hitler was a satisfying F U to the long dead dictator.
ACHIEVEMENT IN PRODUCTION DESIGN WINNER: “Once Upon A Time… In Hollywood” (Production Design: Barbara Ling, Set Decoration: Nancy Haigh)
My Pick: “Once Upon A Time… In Hollywood” (Production Design: Barbara Ling, Set Decoration: Nancy Haigh)
I agree with The Academy’s decision on this one. The production design on the film was great! I don’t have much to say about it.
ACHIEVEMENT IN COSTUME DESIGN WINNER: “Little Women” (Jacqueline Durran)
My Pick: “Little Women” (Jacqueline Durran)
I LOVED the costuming in “Little Women!” Durran created costumes that fit the period and individualized the characters in such a unique and beautiful way. The fact that she gave each March sister a specific color palette was such a subtle detail that gave each sister a distinct spirit. I have always enjoyed Jacqueline Durran’s work in the past and she did not let me down in “Little Women.”
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A SUPPORTING ROLE WINNER: Laura Dern in “Marriage Story”
My Pick: Florence Pugh in “Little Women”
Listen, I love Laura Dern. She’s a great actress. She did a good job in “Marriage Story,” but it was not an Oscar worthy performance. She played a tough-as-nails divorce lawyer that was all about female power and being a boss bitch. It was entertaining, but it wasn’t groundbreaking. I think many actresses could have played this part and do it well. Florence Pugh, on the other hand, changed an entire narrative. She took Amy, one of the most hated characters in all of literature, and made her likable. I even heard people saying that she was their favorite character. People who had been fuming for years because Jo and Laurie didn’t end up together were suddenly declaring that Amy and Laurie were perfect for each other after this movie and it’s all because of how Florence portrayed Amy. Where Amy was once calculated, spiteful, and spoiled, she became naïve, childlike, and willing to be better. While watching “Little Women,” I honestly forgot that I was supposed to be resenting Amy. Plus, she was completely convincing at both of Amy’s ages. I never would have known that she wasn’t twelve in the flashbacks if I didn’t come into the movie knowing she was 24 years old. She was sweet and innocent. She stole audiences’ hearts and I think the Oscar was stolen from her.
(I was originally going to discuss the Achievement in Sound Mixing and Achievement in Sound Editing Winners here, but I eventually decided against it. It has been a hot button topic on the internet recently that seemingly no one understands the difference between these two categories, and unfortunately, I identify with this. I am not qualified to discuss Sound Mixing and Editing as I do not understand it, but if you would like to understand the difference between the two, go here. )
ACHIEVEMENT IN CINEMATOGRAPHY WINNER: “1917” (Roger Deakins)
My Pick: “1917” (Roger Deakins)
I don’t have a lot to say about the cinematography category. The “1917” cinematography was stunning. It had me in tears at the theater and I remember thinking while watching it that it was revolutionary for the movie industry. The one-take approach was seamless. What else can I say? This film was breath-taking!
ACHIEVEMENT IN FILM EDITING WINNER: “Ford V Ferrari” (Michael McCusker and Andrew Buckland)
My Pick: “Ford V Ferrari” (Michael MCusker and Andrew Buckland)
I have no problem with the Academy’s pick in this category. As far as I could tell, the editing on this film was done well and I’m glad it won.
ACHIEVEMENT IN VISUAL EFFECTS WINNER: “1917” (Guillaume Rocheron, Greg Butler and Dominic Tuohy)
My Pick: “The Irishman” (Pablo Helman, Leandro Estebecorena, Nelson Sepulveda-Fauser and Stephane Grabli)
I can somewhat understand why “1917” was awarded this category. Their visual effects were so subtle and seamless that you kind of forgot that there were visual effects, which is always a good thing. In my opinion though, “The Irishman” deserved the win. Their de-aging technology was flawless. Robert De Niro and Al Pacino looked as if the de-aged at least 20 years! All in all, the visual effects were phenomenal.
ACHIEVEMENT IN MAKEUP AND HAIRSTYLING WINNER: “Bombshell” (Kazu Hiro, Anne Morgan and Vivian Baker)
My Pick: “Bombshell” (Kazu Hiro, Anne Morgan and Vivian Baker)
This was really clear as day to me that “Bombshell” deserved to win this award. The fact that I genuinely was convinced that Charlize Theron WAS Megyn Kelly for a few minutes, goes to show that the makeup team did a phenomenal job. They really transformed their actors into the real Fox News anchors. This was a no-brainer.
BEST INTERNATIONAL FEATURE FILM OF THE YEAR WINNER: “Parasite” (South Korea, Directed by Bong Joon Ho)
My Pick: “Parasite” (South Korea, Directed by Bong Joon Ho)
Again, this was a no brainer. Out of all the international films this year, “Parasite” stuck out in a big way.
ACHIEVEMENT IN MUSIC WRITTEN FOR MOTION PICTURES (ORIGINAL SCORE) WINNER: “Joker” (Hildur Guðnadóttir)
My Pick: “Joker” (Hildur Guðnadóttir)
I completely agree with the Academy on their decision in this category. This score was haunting, and really showed the instability of Arthur Fleck’s mind through its minor cords. Guðnadóttir composed such a unique score that really shown bright in the film’s “quiet” moments and really created an omnipresent character out of the music. It was very well-done.
ACHIEVEMENT IN MUSIC WRITTEN FOR MOTION PICTURES (ORIGINAL SONG) WINNER: “I’m Gonna) Love Again” from “Rocketman” (Music by Elton John, Lyric by Bernie Taupin)
My Pick: “(I’m Gonna) Love Me Again” from “Rocketman” (Music by Elton John, Lyric by Bernie Taupin) OR “Into the Unknown” from “Frozen II” (Music and Lyric by Kristen Anderson-Lopez and Robert Lopez)
I’m pretty satisfied by this category. “(I’m Gonna) Love Me Again” was a brilliantly written song and I’m glad “Rocketman” took this one home, especially since it received next to zero nominations. If “(I’m Gonna) Love Me Again” didn’t win, then I think the award should have gone to “Into the Unknown” from Frozen II. This song took the world by storm. Not only was the song immensely popular, but the construction of the song was immensely intricate. Over all, I’m glad one of these two songs brought home the win.
ACHIEVEMENT IN DIRECTING WINNER: “Parasite” (Bong Joon Ho)
My Pick: “1917” (Sam Mendes)
I have to be honest. As much as I like Bong Joon Ho’s direction, I really wanted Sam Mendes to win this one. The idea to film a WWI movie in seemingly one take to make the action feel more real and put the audience in the soldiers’ shoes. I was blown away by the direction of “1917” felt revolutionary to me. I’m glad Bong Joon Ho took home the award because it definitely broke boundaries, but I do think Mendes’ direction should have gotten recognition.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A LEADING ROLE WINNER: Joaquin Phoenix in “Joker”
My Pick: Joaquin Phoenix in “Joker” OR Adam Driver in “Marriage Story”
This was a hard category. I was happy with the results, but I would have been thrilled if the award had gone to Adam Driver. Driver gave such a raw, real performance. I was taken aback by his acting ability. I was no longer watching an actor, but a struggling, desperate man trying to fight for his son and put the pieces of his life together during a progressively messier and messier divorce. It was devastating. That being said, I am thrilled that Joaquin Phoenix won. Some movies make actors and some actors make movies. Joaquin Phoenix MADE “Joker.” This movie would not have been the success it was if a different actor had played Arthur Fleck. He exuded the slow insanity, and tragic well-meaning that was needed to portray Arthur and the malice and unnamed evil to eventually become Arthur’s alter ego Joker. It was a haunting performance, and although I do believe Adam Driver should have been recognized, Phoenix’s Oscar was well-deserved.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A LEADING ROLE WINNER: Renée Zellweger in “Judy”
My Pick: Saoirse Ronan in “Little Women”
I love Renée Zellweger, I really do, but I don’t think the Oscar should have gone to her. She did a good job as Judy Garland, but “Judy” felt like Oscar bait to me. Biopics always tend to do well, so I wasn’t surprised that Zellweger won. I think the Academy also felt bad because Judy Garland never won an Academy Award while she was alive, so this win was for Zellweger was like an award for both of them. On the other hand, Saoirse Ronan is the youngest 4-time nominee for good reason. Her performance in “Little Women” was spell-binding. She was relatable and sympathetic. Her version of Jo has my heart and I wish she was awarded for it. Fortunately, I think it won’t be long until Ronan gets her overdue Oscar.
BEST MOTION PICTURE OF THE YEAR WINNER: “Parasite” (Kwak Sin Ae and Bong Joon Ho, Producers)
My Pick: “Parasite” (Kwak Sin Ae and Bong Joon Ho, Producers)
I am ecstatic that “Parasite” won Best Picture. It was more than deserved and it broke boundaries in the film industry by becoming the first international film to win Best Picture. That being said, I don’t believe it won for the right reasons. I believe the Academy was desperate to prove how diverse it is by voting for “Parasite” instead of voting for it based on merit. I am all for diversity, but I think the merit of the actor or director or the movie should go above how diverse they are. Fortunately, I do believe “Parasite” was worthy of this award. If it had gone to a lesser movie just for the sake of diversity, I would have been disappointed. “Parasite” is an intelligent and well-crafted movie and I’m glad it came out on top.
Thank you for reading my opinions of the 2020 Academy Awards! Hopefully, you agreed with my opinions or at least thought my opinions were interesting. If you disagreed with me, feel free to leave a comment and tell me why! With that said, we are living in a critical world and I am a Critical Girl.
.